Did Nicole Scherzinger Leave The Masked Singer? Everything You Need to Know
Nicole Scherzinger has been a fan-favorite judge on The Masked Singer since the show first hit TV screens in 2019. With her sharp guesses, powerhouse voice, and bubbly personality, she’s become a big part of what makes the show so fun to watch. But lately, fans have been buzzing with one big question: Did Nicole Scherzinger leave The Masked Singer for good? If you’ve been wondering about her absence, what she’s up to now, and whether she’ll ever return, you’re in the right place. This article dives deep into everything you need to know—way beyond the quick headlines you’ve probably seen elsewhere.
Let’s break it down step by step, from why she stepped away to what her future with the show might hold. Plus, we’ll explore some angles that other articles haven’t touched on yet—like how her departure has shifted the show’s vibe and what fans are saying about it in 2025. Grab a snack, settle in, and let’s get to the bottom of this mystery!
Why Did Nicole Scherzinger Step Away from The Masked Singer?
Nicole didn’t leave The Masked Singer because of drama or because she was tired of the gig. In fact, she’s said over and over how much she loves being part of the show. So, what happened? It all comes down to timing and a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
In 2023, after Season 10 wrapped up, Nicole got the chance to star in a revival of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical Sunset Boulevard on London’s West End. She took on the lead role of Norma Desmond, a faded silent film star dreaming of a comeback. The show kicked off in September 2023 and ran for 16 weeks, overlapping with the filming schedule for The Masked Singer Season 11. Since the show isn’t filmed live (it’s pre-recorded months ahead of airing), Nicole had to choose: stay with The Masked Singer or chase her dream of performing in a major musical. She picked the latter.
Here’s the kicker: her decision paid off big time. Nicole’s performance was a hit, earning her the Best Actress in a Musical award at the 2024 Laurence Olivier Awards—the UK’s version of the Tonys. Critics raved about her, with The New York Times calling her “captivating.” She told the paper, “For years, I’ve felt like I was only using a fraction of my potential, and now I’ve really tapped into that.” Clearly, this wasn’t just a side gig—it was a game-changer for her career.
But that’s not the end of the story. In March 2024, it was announced that Sunset Boulevard would move to Broadway, with Nicole reprising her role starting in September 2024. That timing clashed with Season 12 of The Masked Singer, meaning she’d miss another round. And then, in mid-2024, she signed on to judge a new Netflix show called Building the Band, adding yet another layer to her busy schedule. So, her absence isn’t about leaving the show behind—it’s about juggling some seriously exciting projects.
What Does This Mean for Her Masked Singer Future?
Nicole’s departure isn’t permanent—at least, not officially. Fox has been cagey about long-term casting, saying only that “no decisions have been made beyond Season 12.” Before she left, Nicole gushed to Entertainment Weekly, “Oh my gosh, I would love to [keep coming back], are you kidding me? I love my Masked Singer family. It’s such a great job!” Her passion for the show is clear, but her packed calendar might keep her away longer than fans hope.
Who Replaced Nicole Scherzinger on The Masked Singer?
Enter Rita Ora, the British pop star who stepped into Nicole’s spot starting with Season 11 in 2024. Rita’s no stranger to the Masked Singer world—she’d already been a judge on the UK version for four seasons. When Fox announced her as Nicole’s replacement in September 2023, they posted on Instagram, “We’re grateful to have the amazing @ritaora shine her light and join us as a panelist!” Rita was thrilled too, writing, “So happy the secret is finally out. I’m joining @maskedsingerfox US! Can’t wait to guess who’s behind the mask.”
Rita’s brought her own flair to the panel, joining regulars Robin Thicke, Ken Jeong, and Jenny McCarthy Wahlberg. She’s got a knack for spotting clues and a playful energy that fits the show’s quirky vibe. But how does she stack up to Nicole? Let’s break it down:
| Judge | Strengths | Style |
|---|---|---|
| Nicole Scherzinger | Amazing voice, spot-on guesses, emotional reactions | Warm, enthusiastic, musical |
| Rita Ora | Clue-catching skills, reality TV experience, fresh perspective | Cool, confident, cheeky |
Fans have mixed feelings. Some miss Nicole’s big personality and her habit of singing along with contestants (she’s belted out hits like “Purple Rain” and “Memory” on the show). Others think Rita’s a solid fit, especially since she’s already a pro at the Masked Singer game. Jenny McCarthy Wahlberg told Entertainment Weekly, “Rita had some big shoes to fill, but she’s been amazing. We love Nicole, but we’re happy for her too.”
Interactive Poll: Who Do You Prefer?
Let’s hear from you! Vote below and see what other fans think:
- Option 1: Nicole Scherzinger—bring her back!
- Option 2: Rita Ora—she’s the perfect replacement.
- Option 3: I like them both equally.
(Check back later for results!)
How Has Nicole’s Absence Changed The Masked Singer?
Nicole’s exit has shifted the show’s dynamic more than you might expect. She wasn’t just a judge—she was a vibe. Here’s how things feel different without her, based on fan chatter trending on X in early 2025 and my own take after watching Seasons 11 and 12:
- Less Musical Magic
Nicole often jumped in to sing with contestants or the panel, turning random moments into mini-concerts. Remember her duet with Jewel on “Dream On” in Season 6? Or her tearful reaction to Dick Van Dyke’s reveal in Season 9? Rita’s talented, but she hasn’t matched that level of musical spontaneity yet. - Shift in Guessing Style
Nicole earned the nickname “Sherlock Scherzy” from host Nick Cannon because of her uncanny ability to guess contestants. Her background with the Pussycat Dolls and The X Factor gave her an edge. Rita’s good at clues too, but her guesses lean more on pop culture than industry insider knowledge. - Emotional Connection
Nicole wore her heart on her sleeve—crying, cheering, geeking out over legends like Van Dyke. That raw emotion connected with viewers. Rita’s cooler and more composed, which some fans love, but it’s less of a rollercoaster.
What Fans Are Saying in 2025
Trending discussions on X in March 2025 show a split. Some fans are all in for Rita: “She’s killing it—fresh energy!” Others are begging for Nicole’s return: “The show’s not the same without her voice and vibes.” A few even suggest a wild twist—Nicole coming back as a contestant to surprise everyone. Imagine her unmasking after stumping the panel she used to sit on!
What’s Nicole Scherzinger Doing Now in 2025?
As of March 27, 2025, Nicole’s busier than ever. Here’s the latest scoop on her projects, straight from the headlines and her own updates:
- Broadway Star: Sunset Boulevard
After its West End success, Sunset Boulevard hit Broadway in September 2024, with Nicole still playing Norma Desmond. Previews started on September 28, and the official opening was October 20. She’s been pouring her heart into it, telling People, “This is where my talents truly lie. I’m still proving myself.” The show’s run is set to continue into mid-2025, so she’s locked in for now. - Netflix’s Building the Band
Nicole’s also a judge on Building the Band, a new Netflix reality show that premiered in early 2025. Singers form bands without seeing each other, relying on chemistry alone. She’s joined by Kelly Rowland and Liam Payne (yep, the One Direction guy she helped discover on The X Factor). It’s a cool twist on the singing competition format, and Nicole’s detective skills from The Masked Singer are coming in handy. - Personal Life Glow-Up
Between gigs, Nicole’s been soaking up life with her fiancé, Thom Evans. They got engaged in 2023, and she’s been posting dreamy vacation pics from spots like Greece and Hawaii. She’s balancing work and play like a pro.
Could She Juggle The Masked Singer Too?
Here’s a quick reality check: Season 13 of The Masked Singer started filming in October 2024, overlapping with Sunset Boulevard’s Broadway debut. Add Building the Band to the mix, and her schedule’s a jigsaw puzzle. Unless something shifts—like Sunset Boulevard wrapping early or Netflix filming winding down—Nicole’s return might not happen until Season 14 in late 2025 or 2026.
3 Things You Haven’t Heard About Nicole’s Masked Singer Exit
Most articles stick to the basics: Nicole left for Sunset Boulevard, Rita took over, end of story. But there’s more to unpack. Here are three angles that haven’t gotten enough attention:
1. The Fan Backlash Nobody’s Talking About
While Rita’s been welcomed by many, a vocal chunk of fans isn’t happy—and it’s not just about missing Nicole. On X in early 2025, some accused Fox of “pushing Nicole out” to shake up the panel, even though there’s no evidence of that. Others say the show’s lost its heart without her emotional spark. One trending post read, “Nicole was the glue. Rita’s fine, but it’s not the same family feel.” This backlash hints at a deeper loyalty to the original lineup that Fox might not have expected.
2. How Nicole’s Exit Ties to a Bigger Career Pivot
Nicole’s not just taking a break—she’s rebranding. After years as a pop star and TV judge, Sunset Boulevard and Building the Band signal a shift toward theater and mentorship. She told The New York Times she felt “discarded” by the music industry at times, and these projects are her way of reclaiming her narrative. Leaving The Masked Singer wasn’t just about scheduling—it’s part of a bigger plan to show the world she’s more than a Pussycat Doll or a guessing-game judge.
3. The Ripple Effect on the Panel’s Chemistry
Robin, Ken, Jenny, and Nicole had a rhythm after 10 seasons—think of them as a band hitting all the right notes. Rita’s addition changes the tune. Ken’s still the wild card, Jenny’s the skeptic, Robin’s the smooth talker, but Rita’s cooler vibe doesn’t quite fill Nicole’s warm, musical niche. It’s not bad—just different. And that shift might explain why some fans feel Season 12 (airing now in March 2025) has a slightly less cozy vibe.
Will Nicole Scherzinger Ever Return to The Masked Singer?
This is the million-dollar question. Let’s weigh the possibilities with a pros-and-cons rundown:
Reasons She Might Come Back
✔️ She Loves It: Nicole’s said she adores the show and her “Masked Singer family.” That’s a strong pull.
✔️ Fan Demand: The outcry on social media could pressure Fox to bring her back once her schedule clears.
✔️ Temporary Swap: Rita was billed as a fill-in, not a permanent replacement, leaving the door open.
Reasons She Might Stay Away
❌ Busy Schedule: With Sunset Boulevard and Building the Band rolling into 2025, she’s booked solid.
❌ New Chapter: Her focus on theater and mentoring might mean she’s outgrown the judge’s chair.
❌ Rita’s Momentum: If Rita keeps winning over fans, Fox might stick with her long-term.
My Prediction (Based on What We Know in March 2025)
I’d bet on a cameo before a full return. Picture this: Nicole pops in as a guest judge for a special episode in Season 13 or 14, maybe even sings a duet with a contestant. It’d be a win-win—fans get their fix, and she keeps her Broadway spotlight. A permanent comeback? That’s trickier. If Sunset Boulevard extends or she lands another big role, we might not see her back in the judge’s seat until 2026—or later.
Interactive Quiz: How Well Do You Know Nicole’s Masked Singer Moments?
Think you’re a superfan? Test your memory with this quick quiz! Jot down your answers and check them at the end.
- What nickname did Nick Cannon give Nicole for her guessing skills?
a) Detective Diva
b) Sherlock Scherzy
c) Clue Queen - Which song did Nicole sing with Jewel in Season 6?
a) “Sweet Child o’ Mine”
b) “Dream On”
c) “Bohemian Rhapsody” - Who did Nicole cry over when they unmasked in Season 9?
a) Dick Van Dyke
b) Donny Osmond
c) Wayne Brady
(Answers: 1-b, 2-b, 3-a. How’d you do? Share your score in the comments!)
What Can Fans Do While Waiting for Nicole’s Next Move?
Missing Nicole on The Masked Singer? Here’s how to stay connected to her world and keep the fun going:
- Catch Sunset Boulevard on Broadway
If you’re near New York (or planning a trip), grab tickets to see Nicole live. It’s running through at least mid-2025, and it’s a chance to witness her in a whole new light. Pro tip: Book early—her Olivier win means seats are selling fast! - Binge Building the Band on Netflix
The show dropped in early 2025, and it’s a fresh way to see Nicole’s judging skills in action. Bonus: You might spot some Masked Singer-style sleuthing as she helps singers find their bandmates. - Rewatch Her Best Masked Singer Moments
Fox’s website and Hulu have full episodes. Relive her duets, wild guesses, and that time she dressed as Catwoman for DC Superheroes Night in Season 9. It’s like a Nicole highlight reel! - Follow Her on Social Media
Nicole’s Instagram (@nicolescherzinger) is packed with updates—Broadway behind-the-scenes, vacation snaps with Thom, and maybe a hint about her Masked Singer plans. Give her a follow and drop a comment cheering her on!
A Deeper Look: How Nicole’s Journey Reflects a Bigger Trend
Nicole’s story isn’t just about one star stepping away from a TV show—it’s part of a bigger shift in entertainment. More celebs are ditching predictable gigs for passion projects. Think Lady Gaga going from pop hits to A Star Is Born, or Zendaya jumping from Disney to Dune. Nicole’s move to theater and mentorship shows she’s not content to stay in one lane. And honestly? That’s inspiring.
A 2024 study from the Entertainment Industry Foundation found that 68% of performers feel pressured to “reinvent” themselves every few years to stay relevant. Nicole’s doing just that—proving she’s got range beyond the Masked Singer desk. It’s a reminder for all of us: sometimes stepping away from what’s comfy can lead to something amazing.
Final Thoughts: Nicole’s Legacy and What’s Next
Nicole Scherzinger didn’t leave The Masked Singer because she wanted to—she left because she had to, chasing dreams that couldn’t wait. As of March 2025, she’s shining on Broadway, mentoring on Netflix, and living her best life with Thom. Rita Ora’s holding down the fort, but Nicole’s mark on the show—those guesses, those songs, that heart—isn’t going anywhere.
Will she return? Maybe not soon, but the door’s not locked. For now, her absence is a chance to cheer her on in this new chapter and enjoy Rita’s take on the panel. One thing’s for sure: whether she’s unmasking celebs or stealing the stage, Nicole’s still a superstar.
What do you think—should Nicole come back, or is Rita the future of The Masked Singer? Drop your thoughts below, and let’s keep the conversation going!
No comment